Challenges Faced by Indian Airlines: A Business Case Study

Introduction

The Indian aviation industry has seen significant growth, but many Indian airlines have faced challenges and failures. This case study delves into the reasons behind the downfall of some prominent Indian airlines and the complexities they encountered.

Challenges Faced by Indian Airlines and the Case of Go First

• India’s aviation industry has seen rapid growth, with a record 4.30 lakh people taking domestic flights this year.

• Despite the growth, many Indian airlines are facing significant challenges, with a history of 13 airlines failing in the last 20 years.

• Go First, formerly known as SpiceJet, faced turbulence due to engine failures, resulting in the grounding of 50% of their aircraft.

• The Wadia family, owners of Go First, encountered issues with Pratt and Whitney engines, leading to operational disruptions.

• In contrast, rival airline IndiGo took proactive measures by partnering with CFM International to address engine-related problems.

• The challenges faced by Go First highlight the complexities and financial implications of engine failures in the aviation industry.

The Downfall of First and Kingfisher Airlines

• The failure of First and Kingfisher Airlines can be attributed to various management and strategic issues.

• In the case of First Airlines, management instability due to family disputes and neglect of employee welfare led to a significant decrease in staff and customer satisfaction.

• The abrupt cancellation of flights and lack of proper communication with customers resulted in financial losses for First Airlines.

• On the other hand, Kingfisher Airlines faced challenges due to poor governance, financial mismanagement, and a flawed business model that attempted to cater to both luxury and budget travelers.

• Despite initial success and recognition as a premium airline, Kingfisher Airlines failed to sustain its operations, leading to massive financial losses and legal troubles.

The Rise and Fall of Kingfisher Airlines

• In 2005, Kingfisher Airlines entered the Indian aviation market with ambitious plans to revolutionize air travel by offering a premium flying experience.

• In 2011, the airline faced a significant challenge as it reported losses for three consecutive years, leading to financial turmoil.

• The CEO turnover at Kingfisher Airlines raised concerns about the company’s strategic direction, with conflicting visions and lack of experience impacting its operations.

• Following attempts to pivot towards a premium segment and boost Kingfisher Red, the airline ultimately had to shut down the operations of Kingfisher Red after a year.

• The financial troubles and mismanagement at Kingfisher Airlines were emblematic of broader issues in the Indian aviation market, including controversial government decisions and unique market dynamics.

The Rise and Fall of Deccan Airlines

• Deccan Airlines initially gained popularity by offering tickets that were 40-50% cheaper than other airlines in the market.

• They introduced a dynamic pricing model called ‘Diana Fans’ in July 2004, where early ticket buyers could secure cheaper fares, disrupting the traditional pricing strategy in the industry.

• The rapid expansion of Deccan Airlines led to operational challenges, as they were operating 380 flights daily by 2007, and struggled to manage increasing costs.

• The airline’s inability to pass on the rising costs to consumers, combined with intense competition from other low-cost carriers like SpiceJet and Indigo, resulted in a loss of popularity for Deccan Airlines.

• The cost dynamics of the aviation industry in India, particularly the high fuel costs, further added to the challenges faced by airlines.

• The complexities around Aviation Turbine Fuel (ATF) taxation and the dependence on imported crude oil created significant cost fluctuations for airlines, impacting their profitability.

• Many airlines, including Indigo, have urged the government to bring ATF under the GST system to reduce tax rates and provide input tax credit, thereby alleviating the financial burden on airlines.

• Additionally, the fluctuation in oil prices and currency valuation, such as the Indian Rupee, significantly affect the operating costs and profitability of airlines in India.

Overview of the Indian Aviation Industry

• The Indian aviation industry is experiencing growth despite challenges such as currency devaluation, government policies, and global economic factors.

• India’s domestic transportation market is the third largest in the world, contributing 5% to the Indian GDP.

• The industry has seen a significant increase in demand with domestic passenger traffic reaching record levels, indicating a thriving market.

• The Indian government has introduced new policies to promote the aviation sector, allowing easier access to international routes and affordable air travel for citizens.

• Despite the growth, challenges remain, as some airlines have faced financial difficulties and require government assistance to ensure sustainability and efficiency.

• The aviation industry is a critical contributor to job creation and economic development in India, with over 40 lakh people employed in the sector.

Conclusion

The complexities and financial implications of challenges faced by Indian airlines, as highlighted in the case studies of Go First, Kingfisher Airlines, and Deccan Airlines, provide valuable insights for the aviation industry. Understanding the dynamics of the Indian aviation market is crucial for sustainable growth and success.

undefined